Best Fish Frys in Sheboygan County: Local Favorites and Award-Winning Plates
From the bustling supper clubs of Sheboygan to the hidden taverns along winding county roads, Friday night fish fry isn’t just a meal here—it’s a tradition. In Sheboygan County, the scent of sizzling perch, walleye, and bluegill drifts through the air every week, drawing in locals and visitors alike. Many spots source fresh catches right from Lake Michigan, adding to the flavor and pride behind every plate. Whether you’re chasing an award-winning fry, a hometown favorite passed down for generations, or a casual bar with all-you-can-eat cod, this guide ranks the very best places to grab a fish fry—starting with the ones Sheboygan County swears by.
Here’s the short list locals actually use—ranked by hometown favorites and real awards—so you can plan your next Friday right now.
Scenic Bar & Restaurant — 1635 Indiana Ave, Sheboygan • (920) 452-2881 • scenicbar.com
Classic Wisconsin fish fry done right (perch, bluegill, cod), generous portions, friendly service, and the community’s current bragging rights: publicly celebrated as Sheboygan County’s “best fish fry” for 2025. If you want the line-out-the-door local favorite, this is it. Take the Scenic Route! Facebook
Majerle’s Black River Grill — 5033 Evergreen Dr, Sheboygan • (920) 803-5115 • blackrivergrill.com
Supper-club vibe tucked in the pines near the Black River, with a Friday fish fry plate and frequent bluegill, perch, haddock, and walleye specials. It’s the spot you’ll hear recommended by Sheboygan die-hards again and again. Majerle’s Black River Grill Yelp
Gosse’s at The Northwestern House — 1909 Union Ave, Sheboygan • (920) 457-8696 • thenorthwesternhouse.com
A Sheboygan institution serving a fish fry every day and touting “Best of the Best” wins for Fish Fry, Chicken, and more—old-school rye bread, slaw, and that perfectly crisped fish. thenorthwesternhouse.com
Chris & Sue’s — W3820 County Rd C, Plymouth • (920) 467-3223 • chrisandsuesplace.com
Country-road gem with an “award-winning fish fry” and potato-pancake comfort. Small-town hospitality, big repeat-customer energy—go early. Chris & Sue’s
PJ Campbell’s at The Depot — 114 Depot Rd, Plymouth • (920) 893-8600 • pjcampbellsatthedepot.com
Historic depot setting; Friday means perch, cod, and Cajun catfish on rotation. German sides, generous pours, and Road America weekend buzz. SinglePlatform pjcampbellsatthedepot.com
Ranieri’s Four of a Kind — 811 Indiana Ave, Sheboygan • (920) 458-0458 • fourofakind-sheboygan.com
Casual downtown favorite with all-you-can-eat cod on Fridays (lunch and dinner windows) and fresh local fish sourced from Schwarz Fish Co. when available—very “Sheboygan.” Facebook
Horse & Plow (The American Club) — 419 Highland Dr, Kohler • (920) 451-2178 • kohlerwisconsin.com/dining/horse-and-plow
Polished pub inside The American Club; the Walleye Fish Fry is the move if you want a refined take without losing Wisconsin soul.
Quit Qui Oc Golf Club Restaurant — 500 Quit Qui Oc Ln, Elkhart Lake • (920) 876-2833 • quitquiocgolf.com
A county-wide standby; their dedicated Friday Fish Fry menu runs 4:30–9:00 pm with perch, bluegill, and cod options. Family-friendly, reservations recommended. Quit Qui Oc Golf Club & Restaurant
Bump’s Grill Tavern (Home of the Liars Club) — 1902 S 12th St, Sheboygan • (920) 452-4669 • bumpsgrilltavern.com
Neighborhood bar that locals swear by for walleye and perch; straightforward menu, fair prices, and Friday fish fry posted weekly. bumpsgrilltavern.com Yelp
Otto’s Restaurant (The Osthoff) — 101 Osthoff Ave, Elkhart Lake • (920) 876-3366 • osthoff.com
All-you-can-eat fish fry Fridays at the resort—easy pick if you’re in Elkhart Lake and want a relaxed, family setup. fridayfishfryguide.com
Fudgienuckles — 133 W Main St, Glenbeulah • (920) 526-3511
Supper-club spirit with a reputation for having “the best fish fry in downtown Glenbeulah,” per the local chamber. Friendly, lively, and pure small-town Wisconsin. Plymouth Wisconsin Chamber of Commerce
Petek’s Tavern — 2702 S 8th St, Sheboygan • (920) 287-7316
Corner-bar classic with hand-breaded perch and a loyal fan base; a great budget-friendly option that still hits the spot. Facebook visitsheboygan.com
On The House — 1153 High Ave, Sheboygan • (920) 458-6711
Compact grill that keeps getting “best Friday fish fry” shout-outs from regulars; simple, crispy, and very local. fridayfishfryguide.com Yelp
VFW Post 9156 — 552 S Evans St, Sheboygan • (920) 458-9809 • sheboyganvfw9156.org
Community hall fish fry with the kind of old-school vibe (and fresh Lake Michigan species from Schwarz Fish Co. when they run specials) that makes Wisconsin, Wisconsin.
Wild Shots Pub & Grill — 423 E Mill St, Plymouth • (920) 400-4491
Plymouth go-to for baked cod, fried perch, and bluegill—your post-Road America option when you still want a proper Friday fish plate. Facebook
Lakehouse Bar & Restaurant — N8355 County Rd J, Plymouth • (920) 893-5117
Crystal Lake hangout with Friday fish and cocktails by the water—cozy, casual, and close to town. visitsheboygan.com
If you want strictly “fresh from Lake Michigan,” ask servers what they’ve got that came in from Schwarz Fish Co. this week—several spots above call them out by name when perch, whitefish, smelt, or walleye are running.
Got a favorite we missed—or a hot tip on who’s serving the freshest Lake Michigan perch right now? Drop it in the comments so we can keep this local ranking sharp and up to date.
