Schwarz’s Supper Club
Schwarz’s Supper Club in New Holstein, WI, is a cherished local institution renowned for its classic Wisconsin supper club experience. With over 1,800 glowing reviews and an impressive 4.7-star average rating, visitors can expect hearty Midwestern fare, warm hospitality, and a welcoming, nostalgic ambiance. From expertly prepared steaks to signature cocktails, Schwarz’s delivers a memorable evening out for families, friends, and travelers seeking authentic flavors and timeless tradition.
What to Expect
- Menu Highlights: Famous for prime rib, steaks, seafood, and classic supper club sides like baked potatoes and relish trays.
- Atmosphere: Cozy, friendly, and steeped in local tradition—perfect for both special occasions and casual gatherings.
- Service: Known for attentive, personable staff who make every guest feel at home.
Best Times to Visit
- Weekday Evenings: Enjoy a more relaxed atmosphere and shorter waits.
- Fridays & Saturdays: The supper club is busiest on weekends, especially for Friday fish fry and Saturday prime rib. Arrive early to secure a table.
- Sunday: Open earlier in the afternoon, making it ideal for a leisurely family meal.
Local Tips
- Reservations are not accepted; be prepared for a wait during peak hours.
- Enjoy a classic Old Fashioned cocktail at the bar while you wait for your table.
- Dress is casual, but many guests opt for business casual for dinner.
- Check their website for seasonal specials and holiday hours.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What are Schwarz’s Supper Club’s hours of operation?
They are open Sunday 2:30–8 PM, Tuesday 2–9 PM, Wednesday 3–9 PM, Thursday 3:30–8 PM, Friday 3:30–8:30 PM, Saturday 3–9 PM, and closed on Mondays. - Do I need a reservation?
No, Schwarz’s operates on a first-come, first-served basis. Arrive early, especially on weekends. - Is there a dress code?
Dress is generally casual to business casual. Feel free to dress up for special occasions. - What is the most popular dish?
The prime rib is especially popular, along with their steaks and Friday fish fry. - Are there vegetarian options available?
While the menu is focused on meats and seafood, there are a few vegetarian-friendly sides and salads available. - Is Schwarz’s family-friendly?
Yes, families are welcome and there are menu options suitable for children. - Can I host a private event or large group?
Schwarz’s is able to accommodate larger groups; call ahead to discuss options and availability. - Is there a bar area?
Yes, the bar is a classic part of the supper club experience—perfect for cocktails before dinner. - What payment methods are accepted?
Major credit cards and cash are accepted. - Is parking available?
Yes, there is ample on-site parking for guests. - Do you offer takeout?
Yes, takeout is available. Check the website or call for details and ordering.
Schwarz’s Supper Club
New Holstein
WI
53061
(920) 894-3598
https://schwarzsupperclub.com/
Contacts: Email LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Instagram
Schwarz’s Supper Club, W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061 (920) 894-3598
– Sunday: 2:30to 8 PM
– Monday: Closed
– Tuesday: 2to 9 PM
– Wednesday: 3to 9 PM
– Thursday: 3:30to 8 PM
– Friday: 3:30to 8:30 PM
– Saturday: 3to 9 PM
Average rating of 4.7 from 1832 on Google
Schwarz’s Supper Club https://schwarzsupperclub.com/
