Schwarz’s Supper Club

Schwarz’s Supper Club is a beloved dining destination in New Holstein, Wisconsin, renowned for its classic supper club experience and warm, welcoming atmosphere. With a stellar 4.7 average rating from over 1,800 reviews, it has become a favorite for locals and visitors seeking hearty American fare, expertly mixed cocktails, and traditional Wisconsin hospitality. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a perfectly cooked steak or prime rib, Schwarz’s delivers a memorable meal in a timeless setting.

Highlights

• Famous for its steaks, prime rib, and classic supper club cocktails
• Charming, retro-inspired ambiance with friendly, attentive service
• Ideal for groups, family gatherings, and special celebrations
• Full bar with Wisconsin favorites like Old Fashioneds and craft beers

Cost Range

• Appetizers: $7 – $15
• Main Courses: $20 – $45 (specialty steaks and seafood at higher end)
• Drinks: $5 – $12

Best Times to Visit

• Weekends: Arrive early or call ahead, as the supper club is very popular and can fill up quickly.
• Weekdays: Less crowded, especially for early dinners.
• Special occasions and holidays: Reservations strongly recommended.

Local Tips

• Try the house specialty Old Fashioned for a true Wisconsin experience.
• Expect a traditional supper club sequence: cocktails at the bar first, followed by your meal.
• Portions are generous—consider sharing sides or dessert.
• Casual to smart-casual dress is typical; no formal attire required.

Parking Advice

• Ample free parking is available onsite.
• Arrive a bit early on busy nights to secure a convenient spot.

Frequently Asked Questions

• What type of cuisine does Schwarz’s Supper Club serve?
  They specialize in classic American fare, with an emphasis on steaks, prime rib, seafood, and traditional supper club favorites.
• Do I need a reservation?
  Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends and holidays, but walk-ins are welcome when space allows.
• Is there a dress code?
  Casual to smart-casual attire is appropriate; there is no formal dress code.
• Is Schwarz’s Supper Club family-friendly?
  Yes, families are welcome and there are menu options for children.
• Does the supper club offer vegetarian or gluten-free options?
  While the menu is focused on meat and seafood, some vegetarian and gluten-free options are available; ask your server for details.
• What is the atmosphere like?
  The setting is classic, cozy, and friendly, with a retro supper club feel and welcoming staff.
• Can I host a private event or large group?
  Yes, Schwarz’s Supper Club can accommodate groups and special events; contact them in advance to make arrangements.
• Are there options for takeout?
  Takeout is sometimes available; call ahead to inquire about current policies and menu availability.
• What are the signature drinks?
  The Old Fashioned is a house specialty, alongside a variety of classic cocktails and local beers.
• Is parking available onsite?
  Yes, there is ample free parking for guests right at the supper club.

Schwarz’s Supper Club

Sheboygan
Wisconsin

Contacts: Email LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Instagram

Schwarz’s Supper Club
Schwarz’s Supper Club, W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061
(920) 894-3598
Rating: 4.7 average from 1832 reviews.

Read Reviews
Schwarz’s Supper Club website