Geno Nottolini’s Pizza

Geno Nottolini’s Pizza is a well-known pizza spot in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, offering a cozy environment for dine-in guests, as well as convenient curbside pickup and takeout options. With over 160 Google reviews and a rating of 3.2, Geno Nottolini’s Pizza is recognized among locals for its classic pizza menu and friendly service. Its central location makes it a convenient choice for both residents and visitors exploring the area.

Local Tips

• Order ahead during peak dinner hours to minimize your wait time, especially on weekends.
• The restaurant is a short walk from other local eateries, making it easy to plan a food crawl in the neighborhood.
• Check their website or social media for special offers and seasonal menu items.

Parking Advice

• Street parking is available near the entrance on Indiana Ave.
• Arrive early during weekends or popular dining hours, as parking can fill up quickly.

Best Times to Visit

• Weekday afternoons tend to be quieter, ideal for a relaxed meal.
• Friday and Saturday evenings are busiest—reserve or order ahead if possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

• What types of pizza does Geno Nottolini’s Pizza offer? They serve a variety of classic and specialty pizzas, including both thin and thick crust options.
• Is there a gluten-free menu available? While gluten-free options may be limited, it’s best to contact the restaurant directly for current offerings.
• Are reservations required? Reservations are not required but can be helpful during peak hours, especially for larger groups.
• Does Geno Nottolini’s Pizza offer delivery? No, currently the restaurant offers dine-in, curbside pickup, and takeout, but not delivery.
• What are the payment options? Most major credit cards and cash are accepted.
• Is Geno Nottolini’s Pizza family-friendly? Yes, the restaurant welcomes families and offers a casual, comfortable atmosphere.
• Are there vegetarian options on the menu? Yes, several vegetarian-friendly pizzas and sides are available.
• Can I host a private event or party here? For information on group bookings or special events, contact the restaurant directly.
• Is there outdoor seating? Outdoor seating may be limited or seasonal; call ahead to confirm availability.
• Do they offer any specials or loyalty programs? Specials and promotions are sometimes available—check their website or social media for the latest deals.

Geno Nottolini’s Pizza

Sheboygan
Wisconsin
53081
+1 920-458-4505
https://www.genonottolinispizzamenu.com/?utm_source=gbp

Contacts: Email LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Instagram

3.2 average rating from 165 reviews for Geno Nottolini’s Pizza

Explore the authentic taste of pizza at Geno Nottolini’s Pizza in Sheboygan, Wisconsin. With an average rating of 3.2 from 164 Google reviews, this popular restaurant offers a variety of dining options including dine-in, curbside pickup and takeout. Located conveniently at 1235 Indiana Ave – just a short stroll from AK’s Twisted Chicken – it is open for service Wednesday through Sunday from noon till midnight.

Their extensive menu can be accessed on slicelife.com where customers also have the option to place their orders online or via phone call at (920) 458-4505. Patrons particularly enjoy their carne asada fries and beverages; however, experiences may vary as indicated by mixed customer feedback.

If you’ve visited Geno Nottolini’s Pizza before, we’d appreciate your thoughts! Feel free to share your reviews and photos with us.

https://sheboyganlife.com/places/geno-nottolinis-pizza/