Gessert’s Ice Cream and Confectionery

Contact Information

Phone: 920-781-2008

Address: 99 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake, WI 53020

Website: gessertsicecream.com, search.google.com

Gessert’s Ice Cream and Confectionery is a cherished local gem in Elkhart Lake, WI, renowned for its nostalgic charm and delectable homemade ice cream. With an impressive average rating of 4.8 from over 340 reviews, Gessert’s has built a loyal following by offering a delightful array of classic and creative flavors, as well as an old-fashioned candy selection. Its inviting atmosphere and attentive service make it a favorite destination for both families and visitors seeking a sweet treat in a vintage setting.

Highlights & Local Tips

Homemade Goodness: Enjoy a wide variety of handcrafted ice cream flavors, sundaes, floats, and shakes.
Classic Candy Counter: Browse a selection of nostalgic candies and confections, perfect for all ages.
Vintage Ambience: The shop’s historic decor and friendly staff enhance the classic ice cream parlor experience.
Family-Friendly: A popular stop for families, especially after a day at the lake or exploring downtown Elkhart Lake.

Cost Range

Single scoop: $3–$4
Sundaes & Floats: $5–$7
Candy selection: Priced by weight or package, typically $2–$8

Best Times to Visit

Weekday afternoons for the most relaxed atmosphere and minimal wait times.
Summer weekends can be busy—consider visiting earlier in the day for quicker service.
Evenings offer a lively, nostalgic vibe, especially during tourist season.

Parking Advice

Street parking is generally available on S Lake St and nearby roads.
Additional public parking lots are within walking distance downtown.
Arrive early during peak summer weekends to secure convenient parking.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Gessert’s most popular ice cream flavors?
Customer favorites include classic vanilla, chocolate, butter pecan, and seasonal specialties like strawberry or pumpkin.
Do they offer non-dairy or vegan options?
Gessert’s occasionally features sorbet or non-dairy selections—call ahead or check in-store for availability.
Is the shop open year-round?
Gessert’s is typically open seasonally; check their website or social media for current hours and seasonal updates.
Can I order custom ice cream cakes or large quantities for events?
Yes, special orders and event catering are available—contact the shop in advance to discuss options.
Is seating available inside or outside?
The shop offers both indoor seating and some outdoor benches, perfect for enjoying treats on sunny days.
Are gift cards available for purchase?
Yes, gift cards can be purchased in-store and make great gifts for any dessert lover.
Do they accept credit cards and cash?
Gessert’s accepts major credit cards as well as cash payments.
Is Gessert’s kid-friendly?
Absolutely! The friendly staff and fun candy selection make it a hit with children of all ages.
Can I bring my dog?
Leashed dogs are welcome outside; some visitors enjoy treats with their furry friends on the outdoor benches.
Is there parking nearby?
Yes, street and public lot parking are available within easy walking distance of the shop.