Sheboygan, Wisconsin is known for its delicious and mouth-watering fish fry, a staple of the city’s cuisine. Whether you’re a local resident or just passing through, you won’t want to miss out on the best fish fry in town. To help you navigate this culinary landscape, we’ve compiled a list of the top fish fry restaurants in Sheboygan, sorted by awards and reviews.

Voted Best Fish Fry in Sheboygan: Scenic Bar & Restaurant

Average rating: 4.6 from 252 reviews
Type of restaurant: $$, Restaurant
Location: 1635 Indiana Ave
What customers are saying about Scenic Bar & Restaurant: “Voted best fish fry in Sheboygan for good reasons!”

By Far the Favorite Friday Fish Fry: Manning’s Irish Pub

Average rating: 4.5 from 208 reviews
Type of restaurant: $, Irish Pub
Location: 3015 N 15th St
What customers are saying about Manning’s Irish Pub: “By far our favorite Friday fish fry in Sheboygan…”

Best Friday Fish Fry in Sheboygan: On the House

Average rating: 4.5 from 50 reviews
Type of restaurant: $, Grill
Location: 1153 High Ave
What customers are saying about On The House: “Best Friday fish fry in Sheboygan!”

Great Friday Fish Fry and Sandwich Menu: Petek’s Tavern

Average rating: 4.6 from 67 reviews
Type of restaurant: $, Bar
Location: 2702 S 8th St, 1.2 mi
What customers are saying about Petek’s Tavern: “Great Friday fish fry and sandwich menu.”

Super Friendly and Amazing Fresh Fish Fry: Ranieri’s Four of A Kind

Average rating: 4.4 from 514 reviews
Type of restaurant: $, Grill
Location: 811 Indiana Ave, near Nine-O-Two on the Avenue
What customers are saying about Ranieri’s Four of A Kind: “Super friendly amazing fresh fish fry and can’t wait to go again.”

Fantastic Friday Fish Fry: The Northwestern House

Average rating: 4.7 from 662 reviews
Type of restaurant: $, Restaurant
Location: 1909 Union Ave
What customers are saying about The Northwestern House: “Fantastic Friday Fish Fry!”

Fantastic Walleye Fish Fry: BUMP’S GRILL TAVERN, HOME OF THE LIARS CLUB

Average rating: 4.5 from 142 reviews
Type of restaurant: $, Restaurant
Location: 1902 S 12th St
What customers are saying about BUMP’S GRILL TAVERN: “Fantastic walleye fish fry.”

Other Top Fish Fry Restaurants in Sheboygan:

Bourbon Street Pub and Grill (average rating 4.4 from 371 reviews)
Al & Al’s Steinhaus (average rating 4.3 from 325 reviews)
Tommy’s Bar (average rating 4.7 from 240 reviews)
NZ’s Bar & Grill (average rating 4.4 from 362 reviews)
Frankie’s Pub & Grill (average rating 4.6 from 699 reviews)
Superior Bar and Grill (average rating 4.5 from 315 reviews)
Schwarz Fish Company (average rating 4.5 from 135 reviews)
Majerle’s Black River Grill (average rating 4.7 from 651 reviews)
Black Pig (average rating 4.4 from 820 reviews)
Urbane (average rating 4.6 from 270 reviews)
Schulz’s Restaurant (average rating 4.5 from 719 reviews)
Parker John’s BBQ & Pizza – Sheboygan (average rating 4.4 from 2.1K reviews)
Holidays Pub & Grill (average rating 4.2 from 687 reviews)

Sheboygan offers a wide range of options for those seeking a delicious and satisfying fish fry experience. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual grill, a cozy Irish pub, or a more upscale restaurant, there’s something for everyone. So, gather your friends and family and head out to one of these top-rated fish fry restaurants in Sheboygan today!

We invite our readers to share their favorite fish fry places in Sheboygan with us. Whether you’re a regular at one of the restaurants listed above, or you have a hidden gem that you think deserves recognition, we would love to hear from you. Leave a comment below and let us know what makes your favorite fish fry spot stand out. Your feedback will help us continue to improve and update this guide for future fish fry seekers in Sheboygan.

Discover the Best Fish Fry in Sheboygan