Schwartz’s supper Club
Schwartz’s Supper Club is a beloved dining destination in New Holstein, Wisconsin, known for its welcoming atmosphere and classic supper club fare. With a strong 4.6-star rating from satisfied guests, this family-friendly establishment offers a quintessential Wisconsin dining experience, featuring generous portions, excellent service, and a menu that celebrates local flavors. Whether you’re seeking a hearty steak, traditional fish fry, or an old-fashioned cocktail, Schwartz’s provides a warm and memorable evening out.
Menu Highlights
- Signature steaks and prime rib
- Friday night fish fry
- Homestyle sides and salads
- Classic Wisconsin old fashioneds
- Homemade desserts
Cost Range
Expect dinner entrees to range from $15 to $35, with appetizers and drinks available at moderate prices, making Schwartz’s Supper Club suitable for both casual outings and special occasions.
Best Times to Visit
- Friday and Saturday evenings: Enjoy the lively supper club tradition and popular fish fry.
- Weekdays: Quieter atmosphere and shorter wait times.
Local Tips
- Reservations are recommended for weekends and holidays.
- Arrive early for a cocktail at the bar, a cherished supper club custom.
- Save room for dessert—house-made pies and cakes are a highlight.
Parking Advice
Ample onsite parking is available, making access easy for groups and families.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What kind of cuisine does Schwartz’s Supper Club serve?
Schwartz’s specializes in classic American supper club fare, including steaks, seafood, and traditional Wisconsin dishes. - Do I need a reservation?
Reservations are highly recommended for weekends, holidays, and large groups, but walk-ins are welcome when space allows. - Is there a dress code?
The atmosphere is casual yet neat; business casual attire is appreciated, but not required. - Is the restaurant family-friendly?
Yes, Schwartz’s is ideal for families and offers menu options for children. - Can I host private events or parties?
Private dining and event options are available—contact the restaurant for details and availability. - Are vegetarian or gluten-free options offered?
Some menu items can be prepared vegetarian or gluten-free; inform your server of dietary needs. - What are the most popular dishes?
The prime rib, Friday fish fry, and homemade desserts are long-time favorites among guests. - Is the bar open to non-dining guests?
Yes, the bar area welcomes guests who wish to enjoy drinks or appetizers without a full meal. - What forms of payment are accepted?
Major credit cards and cash are accepted for payment. - Is there wheelchair accessibility?
The facility offers accessible entrances and seating for guests with mobility needs.
Schwartz’s supper Club
Sheboygan
Wisconsin
Contacts: Email LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Instagram
Schwartz’s supper Club
Schwartz’s supper Club, W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061
Rating: 4.6 average from 5 reviews.
Read Reviews
Schwartz’s supper Club website
