Sheboygan Pasty Company
Sheboygan Pasty Company is a beloved local eatery in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, specializing in traditional pasties—savory, hand-held pastries filled with a variety of hearty ingredients. With a high customer rating of 4.7 from over 75 reviews, this spot has garnered a loyal following for its authentic flavors, warm service, and commitment to quality. Whether you’re seeking a quick lunch, a unique comfort food experience, or a taste of Midwest tradition, Sheboygan Pasty Company stands out as a must-try culinary destination.
Menu Highlights
- Classic beef and vegetable pasties
- Vegetarian and specialty fillings (seasonal offerings available)
- Freshly baked, hand-crimped pastry crusts
Best Times to Visit
- Lunch Hours: The shop is busiest during lunch, so arrive early for the best selection.
- Weekdays: Quieter and faster service, ideal for a relaxed meal.
- Takeout: Convenient for on-the-go meals or picnics by Lake Michigan.
Local Tips
- Pair your pasty with one of their house-made sauces for extra flavor.
- Follow their social media for seasonal specials and limited-time flavors.
- Ask about frozen pasties to bake at home—perfect for busy nights or sharing with friends.
Parking Advice
- Street parking is available along Indiana Ave and nearby side streets.
- Arrive early during peak lunch hours for the best parking options.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is a pasty? A pasty is a savory pastry filled with meats, vegetables, or other ingredients, baked in a golden crust—originating from the UK and popular in Midwest cuisine.
- Do you offer vegetarian or vegan options? Yes, Sheboygan Pasty Company features vegetarian fillings and occasionally offers vegan pasties; ask staff about current selections.
- Can I order pasties to take home and bake later? Frozen pasties are available for purchase so you can enjoy them fresh from your own oven.
- Are there gluten-free options? Gluten-free pasties may be offered on a rotating basis; contact the shop or check their menu for availability.
- Do you deliver or offer online ordering? Check the company website or social media for the latest information on delivery and online ordering services.
- How do I reheat a pasty? For best results, reheat pasties in an oven at 350°F until heated through; microwaving is also possible but may affect crust texture.
- What are the most popular pasty flavors? The classic beef and vegetable pasty is a customer favorite, but seasonal specials are also highly recommended.
- Is seating available for dine-in? Seating options may vary; it’s best to call ahead if you plan to dine in with a group.
- Can I place a large order for events or catering? Yes, advance notice is appreciated for large orders or catering—contact the shop to discuss details.
- Is Sheboygan Pasty Company family-friendly? Absolutely—families are welcome, and pasties are a hit with kids and adults alike.
Sheboygan Pasty Company
Sheboygan
Wisconsin
Contacts: Email LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Instagram
Sheboygan Pasty Company
Sheboygan Pasty Company, 811 A Indiana Ave, Sheboygan, WI 53081
(920) 395-2132
Rating: 4.7 average from 75 reviews.
Read Reviews
Sheboygan Pasty Company website
