Sheboygan County’s Finest Cheeses: The Perfect Dairy Lover’s Gift

ByBrian Bateman
Share

Wisconsin is world-famous for its cheese, and Sheboygan County proudly contributes to that legacy. Whether you’re a cheese connoisseur or just looking for a unique and delicious gift, local creameries and cheese shops offer some of the best artisanal dairy products in the state.

Plymouth: The Cheese Capital of the World

Downtown Plymouth is home to the Cheese Counter & Dairy Heritage Center, a must-visit for anyone who loves high-quality, locally made cheeses. Their “Sheboygan County’s Best” gift box is a standout, featuring an assortment of the region’s finest cheeses, including:

  • Henning’s cheddar – Crafted by a multi-generational family creamery.
  • Gibbsville cheddar – A local favorite known for its rich, aged flavor.
  • Sartori farmhouse cheese – An award-winning cheese from Plymouth’s own Sartori Cheese.
  • Johnsonville summer sausage – A perfect pairing with Wisconsin’s best cheeses.

This curated selection makes an ideal gift, whether you’re shipping it to friends or bringing it to a gathering. It’s a delicious way to share the flavors of Sheboygan County.

Where to Find More Artisanal Cheeses

Many shops throughout Sheboygan County stock Sartori Cheese, one of the area’s most decorated cheesemakers. From creamy BellaVitano to aged Parmesan, Sartori offers something for every palate. Don’t be shy about asking for samples—there’s no better way to find a new favorite cheese to take home.

For locals, these high-quality dairy products are a point of pride. For visitors, they’re an opportunity to taste world-class Wisconsin cheese straight from the source. Whether as a gift or a personal indulgence, Sheboygan County’s cheeses never disappoint.

Sheboygan Life Publisher

Brian Bateman is a lifelong Sheboygan County resident, web developer, and founder of SheboyganLife.com. Inspired by his love for the area and a desire to give back, he created this free, community-driven platform to share local events, stories, and happenings.

A graduate of Plymouth and Sheboygan South High Schools and the UW Center in Sheboygan, Brian has spent his career building digital solutions across Wisconsin for clients around the world.

From local event coverage to boosting small businesses, Brian’s mission is simple: spotlight what makes Sheboygan special, support the locals behind it, and keep the community connected, informed, and on the grow.

More About Sheboygan

Leave a Reply