Best Pizza in Sheboygan Nominations
Reply Below With Your Nomination
Is there anything more universally loved than a slice of pizza? Our next category in the Sheboygan Plate Awards is ‘Best Pizza in Sheboygan.’ Whether you’re a fan of thin crust or deep-dish, traditional toppings or experimental combinations, we’re certain you have a favorite spot that serves up the perfect pie. We want to know where that is! Share your nomination for the best pizza joint in Sheboygan in the comments section below. Your favorite pizzeria could be the next recipient of a Golden Plate Award, but they need your nomination first. Let’s see who really knows how to toss a terrific pizza in Sheboygan! Restaurant Owners
I really enjoy thin crust pizza so I am going to vote for Nicky’s Pizza. They are pretty generous with their toppings and always have been prompt with their delivery. The pizza is very delicious and filling.
Toppers on 8th & Erie has good deals, they’re open late and the thin crust pizza is good. I hear that there’s a New York Pizza place opening on Michigan Ave., so I’ll have to try that as well.
I think Peabody’s is one of the best pizza & subs in the Sheboygan area. Excellent food and customer service. I would like to nominate them